This chapter
on biblical retirement is the crux of the book. Consequently, I’ve been putting it
off because if I do a poor job on it, there is no reason any of you will read
any further! On the other hand, it is a chapter where I'd really like feedback.
One recent conversation with a friend convinced me that I ought to go ahead and get it
out in front of you all. I just hope I don’t disappoint too much as he warned
me, “that chapter better not suck!”
As usual, I can see many flaws in this chapter, but I'll let you discover them for yourself. I'm sure there are more things I will add to this chapter as I write more of the book. For now, I'm resisting the temptation to rewrite any of the chapters I've done so far. I think it will be better to wait until I've written the first draft of all or most of the chapters before doing so. I'm also discovering that figuring out what material belongs in which chapter can be a challenge. For
example, I included something in this chapter about work not necessarily meaning getting paid. That may better belong in the chapter on work with
a reference back to it in this chapter.
I also
decided to combine what had been chapters 1 (What exactly is retirement?) and 3
(Worldly view of retirement) as there was a decent amount of overlap and I
think things flow better with this chapter on biblical retirement following
directly after the one on a biblical view of work.
The two books to the left are the ones I read when I retired. The one by John Piper really is that small and only 30 pages long and I can summarize it in one word, don't! The one by Jeff Haanen is much more useful and worth reading. He includes some good points that I will cover in later chapters of my book.
Now, here is the chapter. Please send me your thoughts!
Biblical Retirement
One of the biggest challenges to
understanding biblical retirement is that the concept of retirement didn’t
really exist in biblical times. In a largely agrarian society with a lower life
expectancy, people did not have the opportunity or expectation to retire. Numbers
8:23-26 is the one direct reference. It specifically says that the Levites
working in the tabernacle were to retire at 50. As we’ll see, it was not what
we typically think of as retirement. The Bible also has plenty so say about
work, service, and personal conduct which is applicable during retirement.
As we saw in Chapter 1, retirement
is largely a modern invention. That makes it unlikely that there would be much
to say about retirement when the Bible was written. Today, we have both a
societal expectation of retirement and the financial wherewithal for many
people to live their later years without needing to make money. There were rich
people in biblical times, however, that did not have to work. We will look at
what the Bible has to say about how they were to live their lives and how that
may apply to retirement.
Christian theologians and scholars
don’t have a lot to say about retirement, but what most seem to say can be
simplified to a single word—don’t. John Piper is a prominent theologian and
author who wrote a small book on retirement titled, Rethinking Retirement:
Finishing Life for the Glory of Christ. In that book he said, “O
God, don’t let me waste my final years! Don’t let me buy the American dream of
retirement—month after month of leisure and play and hobbies and putzing around
in the garage and rearranging the furniture and golfing and fishing and sitting
and watching television. Lord, please have mercy on me. Spare me this curse.” [i] Ben Witherington, III, a
professor and theologian, in a similar vein wrote, “Take, for example, the myth
that our lives should involve a period of work, which, if done well, then
entitles us to retirement, maybe even early retirement! Where exactly is the
notion of retirement found in the Bible? Nowhere!” [ii]
I don’t disagree with either of them
theologically, but I also don’t find their statements particularly useful. Most
of us will retire, at least in the sense that we will stop working to make
money. We live in a time when we can retire and many of us even will be forced
into doing so by job requirements or changes in the job market. Retirement as a
phase of life is not the theological problem. Instead, the issue is what we do
during that period in our lives. As you might expect, we can find good answers
by looking at what God has to say in the Bible.
AGES IN THE BIBLE
Before diving into what the Bible
says about retirement, we need to spend a little time discussing the long lifespans
of people in the first eleven chapters of Genesis as well as later in the Bible.
There are some things we can glean from how people lived in biblical times to retirement
in our day. First, let’s look what the Bible has to tell us. Adam lived 930
years and his son Seth was born when he was 130. Adam had other sons and
daughters after Seth (Genesis 5:3-5). He by no means lived the longest lifespan
as Methuselah is recorded to have lived 969 years (Genesis 5:27). At 182 years,
Lamech became the father of Noah and said, “This one will give us rest from our
work and from the toil of our hands arising from the ground which the
LORD has cursed” (Genesis 5:29). Lamech was lamenting his work and looking for
rest at 182! Noah was 600 when the Flood started and it seems he built the ark
in his 500s (Genesis 7:6). People in the early chapters of Genesis may have
lived a lot longer than we do today, but they did not spend their old age in
retirement.
Not long before the flood, Genesis
6:3 gives some indication that God would limit human lifespan to 120 years.
That number was not a hard cap, however, as the patriarchs lived longer.
Abraham lived to 175 (Genesis 25:7), Isaac to 180 (Genesis 35:28), and Jacob to
l47 (Genesis 47:28). By the time we get to Moses, 120 years (Moses lifespan) was
basically the maximum, much as it is today. The Bible records one exception as
Jehoiada, a Godly priest of the Kingdom of Judah, lived to 130 (2 Chronicles
24:15).
Average life expectancy, however,
was much lower, in part because of high infant mortality. In Jesus day, average
life expectancy was in the thirties or forties. If you made it to adulthood,
you could expect to live to your fifties, sixties, or even seventies. Some
people, however, lived longer. For example, the prophetess Anna is described as
very old at 84 years of age when she was present as Jesus was presented to the
Lord as a baby (Luke 2:37). Interestingly, it says she spent her time in the
“temple, serving night and day with fastings and prayers.” For the purposes of
this chapter, and this book, we can consider living to 100 as an accomplishment
worthy of being on a jar of Smucker’s Jelly. And, living to 120 will make you
the oldest person on the planet for a couple of years. Even if someone only
lives to Anna’s age of 84, statistics indicate will have spent over 20 of those
years in retirement.
RETIREMENT EXAMPLE OF THE LEVITES
During the forty years the
Israelites spend wandering in the wilderness, Moses records the only direct
reference to retirement in the Bible. It is in Numbers 8:23-26 and says,
Now
the Lord spoke to Moses, saying, “This is what applies to the Levites: from
twenty-five years old and upward they shall enter to perform service in the
work of the tent of meeting. But at the age of fifty years they shall retire
from service in the work and not work anymore. They may, however, assist their
brothers in the tent of meeting, to fulfill an obligation, but they themselves
shall do no work. In this way you shall deal with the Levites in their
obligations.”
When God gave these instructions to
Moses, the Levites were working in the tabernacle, as this was a considerable
amount of time before the temple was built. The tabernacle was a tent
surrounded by a large outer set of walls. Exodus 26 and 27 describes it in
detail. The outer portion of the tabernacle was 75 by 150 feet (50 cubits by
100 cubits). The inner section was 15 by 45 feet and 15 feet tall. The
furnishings housed in it were made of wood and various metals and would have
been heavy. The ark of the covenant itself weighed hundreds of pounds and had
to be transported via poles carried on the shoulders of some of the Levites. The
tabernacle was not a camping tent with a few camping chairs inside that could
be folded up and thrown into the back of a pickup truck!
The Bible also describes the duties
of the Levites in great detail. Their duties included the tearing down,
transporting, and erecting of the tabernacle and its furnishings as was
necessitated by the wandering of the Israelites. The fabrics, timbers, and
furniture that needed to be transported and assembled were substantial. Different
groups of Levites (Gershonites, Merarites, and Kohathites) had specific
responsibilities in that process. The physical requirements were different for
the different groups, but they all included strenuous labor. I remember watching
a circus tent go up not far from my house when I was growing up. It required
big ropes, strong men, and lots of work. Putting up the tabernacle in a new
location would have been at least that difficult as they had to work with
heavier materials without the help of motors and vehicles.
Beyond the labor required for
moving the tabernacle, slaughtering large animals for sacrifice was not an easy
task. Sacrificing birds and grain would have been easy. Rams and bulls, however,
were a different matter. It would have taken strength and endurance during
festivals when many animals where sacrificed. Given the heavy manual labor
involved, it is understandable that older Levites would have taken on less
physical work.
With that background on the Levites
and their responsibilities in the tabernacle, let’s now unpack the passage in
Numbers 7. The word in verse 25 that is translated as retire in some
translations, such as the NASB, is shub. In other Bible versions it is
translated as cease, stop, or withdraw. Shub is a very common verb in
the Old Testament that occurs over 1,000 times. At its simplest, it means to
return, restore, or go back.
In verse 25, the word translated as
service is tsaba is a military term most often used regarding service in
the army and indicates hard service. The Hebrew word translated as work is abodah,
which means to labor or serve. This is not the same word translated as work
(melakah) in the Genesis creation account. In verse 26, the word
translated as assist is sharath, which means to minister or serve. The
emphasis seems to be on stopping the strenuous work, not necessarily on less
strenuous work of assisting or serving the Levites under 50.
Regardless of the exact
translation, it is clear that Levites are no longer to do the strenuous work in
the tabernacle. They are, however, to assist the younger Levites. The passage
does not say exactly how they are to assist. It is not difficult to imagine
what that assistance might have been, possibly things like acting as a mentor
to the younger Levites, praying for them, and training them in how to carefully
administer the sacrifices and care for the tabernacle.
The biggest take away to me is that
God is acknowledging capability changes as the Levites aged and the resulting roles
they should play. He is not, however, saying that they should no longer serve. It
doesn’t mean stop working entirely but acknowledges that physically demanding
jobs should not be carried out as the Levites age. The important question for
us is how do we apply this to our lives and our retirement? We should expect
what we can do to change as we age. This is obviously true in physically
demanding jobs. Some people move into management where the demands become less
physical, but not everyone is able or wants to do that.
In my case, my job was not
strenuous other than possibly traveling. I spent my time typing on a computer,
answering emails, and going to meetings. I did find that my work became harder
as I aged. For example, my ability to multitask and jump from one task to
another was not as good as when I was younger. Albert C. Brooks looks at that
issue in his secular book, From Strength to Strength: Finding Success,
Happiness, and Deep Purpose in the Second Half of Life. The essence of is
book is that as we age, our strengths change from quick thinking to wisdom. He
makes the case that rather than lamenting the change we should lean into it.
That may well mean changing our jobs or at least our roles in our jobs. The
book is well worth reading to help understand what is happening to us in our
careers as we age.
Whether we face physical or mental
changes in our careers, we will need to adapt to them. That may mean changing
jobs. Or, it may mean what we consider retirement. As we shall see, that is not
the same as no longer working.
OLD AND GRAY OR YOUNG AND NOT SO GRAY
Much of what we looked at so far
about retirement has been as a function of aging and it may be easy to get
discouraged. It may almost feel like we are being “put out to pasture” as we
age. Psalm 71 is sometimes thought of as the lament of an old person, possibly
David. The last few verses, however, show hope and praise. The writer says in verses
17-18, “O God, You have taught me from my youth and I still declare Your
wonderous deeds. And even when I am old and gray, God, do not abandon me, until
I declare Your strength to this generation, your power to all who are to come.”
The writer is not looking to kick back when old and gray, but to continue
telling the world about the God he worships. It sounds rather like he plans to
teach and mentor the next generation. We were created to serve God through our
work and that does not go away because we age. However, as with the Levites, we
probably won’t do the same work as when we were younger.
Retirement is often thought of as
synonymous with old, or at least somewhat old, age. That is, however, changing.
Many people retire before they are old, by any definition of old. The average
age of retirement in the US is 61 and many people are retiring well before
then. The FIRE (Financial Independence, Retire Early) movement has gained real
traction. The basic tenants of the movement are to maximize savings, reduce
expenses, and invest to create passive income streams. Once you have done
enough of those things, you can afford to retire.
The challenges that someone
retiring in their thirties or forties are not unlike those of people retiring
at a more “normal” age. They are likely, however, to be even more pronounced
when someone retires before their physical or mental capabilities begin to change.
Financial wherewithal is good, but it does not in and of itself provide meaning
or purpose to someone’s life.
Other people face early retirement
not by choice, but because of health problems or being laid off. Being forced
to retire is often even more difficult than retiring early by choice, even if
the financial aspects are not the big issue. The fact that God created us to
work is true regardless of someone’s age, health, or job status.
A THOUGHT EXPERIMENT
In discussing this book, a friend
asked me the following question, “If someone received a substantial, unexpected
inheritance, what should their work look like?” It was a challenging question
that I had not considered. It is, however, central to understanding retirement.
Keller sees work as an inherent need for all of us, beyond that of simply
making money. If the hypothetical person receiving the inheritance no longer
needed to work for the money, that person would still need to work in some way
to fulfill their purpose as God’s image bearer.
The newly rich person could choose
to kick back and do what they feel like doing. They could sleep late, play
pickleball, read, or whatever struck their fancy. Many lottery winners do just
that and find out that instant money doesn’t buy them the happiness they
expected. The lives of the “idle rich” also show that having plenty of money is
not the panacea we might imagine.
The Bible addresses the pitfalls of
being rich. One such passage is in Paul’s letter to his younger protégé, Timothy.
In 1 Timothy 6:18-19, Paul tells him to instruct the rich “to do good, to be
rich in good works, to be generous and ready to share, storing up for
themselves the treasure of a good foundation for the future, so that they may
take hold of that which is truly life.” There is nothing in there about taking
it easy and enjoying life. (We’ll look more at leisure in Chapter 4.) Instead, they
are to do what we are all called to do.
It may not seem like it to us, but
if we are able to retire, we are rich. That doesn’t mean we don’t have to be
careful about how we spend our money, but not having to work is one reasonable
definition of being rich. Paul’s words seem like good instructions for
retirement. For that matter, they are good instructions for life.
NO MAGICAL LINE
The key is that there is no magical
line between working and retirement, no change in God’s expectations for our
lives. The main difference is our greater financial wherewithal and available.
If we retire at an older age, our changing physical and mental capabilities, as
was the case with the Levites, may be another difference. Regardless, God
created us to work and do good works.
William Lane Craig, a contemporary
theologian, attempted to answer the question whether it is wrong to retire. His
response is a bit lengthy, but I’ve included most of it here as it is worth
considering. He said,
Jesus
said, “We must work the works of him who sent me, while it is day; night comes,
when no one can work” (John 9.4). He clearly intended that as his disciples we
should be engaged in the Lord’s work as long as we can, until the end comes. It
would be unthinkable that we should devote the final years of our lives to the
pursuit of pleasure and relaxation. So if we are able to retire from earning an
income because we have planned carefully for our final years, so as to carry
our own expenses and not burden our children financially, nevertheless we never
step back from a life of discipleship, but take up our cross daily to follow
Christ. We should look for ways in which to do the Lord’s work. Of course, ill
health may severely restrict what we can do; but what we must not do is
substitute pleasure-seeking or a leisure lifestyle for following Jesus. It's so
easy to let the world squeeze us into its mold. We often unthinkingly accept
the mores of the culture around us without even realizing it. The Western ideal
of retirement is precisely one such unbiblical assumption.”[iii]
Craig is right to contrast pleasure
and relaxation with work. There is a place for both, and the amount of each
will differ at points in our life. Work never ceases to part of being created
in God’s image. The key in retirement is that we may no longer need to earn
money to live, so what form that work takes on can change. Coupled with the extra
time often available when we retire, we are able to work in a much wider
variety of ways.
He also raises an important point
about disabilities, in retirement or any age. Much of what we covered on
retirement and work has not taken that into account. While the opportunities for
work may well be more limited for someone with a disability, that does not mean
they will not find meaning in work. Where I live there is a coffee shop named
Esteamed Coffee. It provides work for people with disabilities. Its goal is not
just for them to make some money, but to provide the esteem that comes from
doing work. So too, Anna the prophetess in Luke was “very old,” but was able to
continue to work for the Lord through fasting and prayer.
How we live in retirement is
arguably no different from how we should have always lived our lives. The big
changes are that making money is no longer the priority it once was and we have
more time available. That means the freedom to spend our money and time on
God’s work.
Retirement is an amazing
opportunity to restart your life.
UNPAID WORK
It is important to understand that
work is not defined by being paid. Today, we often think of work coming with a
paycheck. Adam and Eve were not paid for their work in the Garden of Eden. It
is not even clear that tending the garden was necessary for them to eat and
survive. Lots of important work may well not be paid work. I defy anyone to
claim that what a housewife or caregiver does is not working. The same is true
of charity work or serving in our local churches.
Once the need to make money is not
a driving concern, the kind of work we can do for God expands greatly. Gene
Edward Veith, Jr. is a professor and author who makes some excellent points in
this regard. He says, “We have callings in different realms—the workplace, yes,
but also the family, the society, and the church. Someone who is retired may no
longer be in the workplace, but he may still pursue his callings as a
grandfather, a concerned citizen, and perhaps as an elder in his church. Some
people find their callings in spheres other than the workplace—a woman who
refuses a job so she can devote herself to her children; the independently
wealthy man who does not need to work, so he devotes himself as a citizen to philanthropy;
the elderly shut-in who devotes her energy, as a Christian, to prayer.” [iv]
One area of work that increases in
importance and possibility once we retire is that of service. Again, the
example of Anna the prophetess in Luke is instructive. She was a widow,
probably of limited means, but she had the time to serve the Lord through
prayer and fasting.
There are many Bible verses
extolling the virtues of serving the Lord through other people. Proverbs 19:17
teaches, “He who is gracious to a poor man lends to the LORD, And He will repay
him for his good deed.” Jesus says in Matthew 25:40, “Truly I say to you, to
the extent that you did it to one of these brothers of Mine, even the
least of them, you did it to Me.” He also says in Mark 10:45, “For even
the Son of Man did not come to be served, but to serve…” We are called to serve
others. Once we retire, we have may more time to do so.
That service is not limited to
serving others at church or other charities, it includes serving our families. Veith
describes to range of service work those of us with time can do. He explains, “The
unemployed, the idle rich, and the retired can find ways of serving their
neighbors. Those who do not have jobs are still members of a family. Even those
without spouses or children generally have parents or siblings, if they are
still alive, or at least cousins and other members of an extended family. They
have a nation and a citizenship to which they have been called. If they are
Christians, they have a church.” [v]
Another thing to keep in mind is
that as we age, our capabilities may change. There are no guarantees that we
will have good health as we age. God understands that and what He expects us to
do may change. One corollary of that fact is that our greatest ability to serve
is probably early in our retirement.
NEXT STEPS
In light of all of this, the next
few chapters will look at some specific areas of our lives we need to consider
when we are retired. One area that we need to examine more closely is that of
leisure. God intends for us to rest (and we often need more of it as we age),
but is leisure the best way to get that rest? We will explore that in the next
chapter. Then, in Chapter 5, we will try to understand the dangers of idleness.
In Chapter 6, we’ll pull all this together to try and understand what God’s
general and specific purposes are for us in retirement.
[i] John Piper, Rethinking
Retirement: Finishing Life for the Glory of Christ. (Wheaton, IL: Crossway
Books). Kindle edition, 28.
[ii] Ben Witherington, III, Work: A
Kingdom Perspective on Labor. (Chicago: Eerdmans, 2011). Kindle edition,
loc. 100.
[iv] Gene Edward Veith, Jr., God at
Work: Your Christian Vocation in All of Life. (Wheaton, IL: Crossway
Books). Kindle edition, 47-48.